My long run playlist had some songs from an unexpected artist this past weekend: Wendy’s.
Yes, that Wendy’s, of fast food burger fame.
Wendy’s released an extended play (EP), Songs to Listen to in a Wendy’s Parking Lot, last week with six pop punk songs that were so catchy that I had to listen to all of them again before I could move on to the next segment of the playlist. This was an out of the blue strategy power play that I would never have anticipated, and I couldn’t wait to learn more post-run.
Let’s rewind.
This all began with Wendy’s sharing an emo-esque photo of Wendy on social media with the simple caption “it was never a phase, album out 9.23.26.” a callback to a classic pop punk trope that listening to this kind of music was just a phase. Within days, the full EP was live on streaming and subsequent posts showed visuals and catchy lyrics from the songs to build hype.
My curiosity got the best of me and I added the EP to my playlist for that weekend’s long run. As a gluten free vegetarian, I can confirm this was already the most attention I’ve paid to Wendy’s in decades.
I’m going to pause here and recommend you take a quick pivot to Spotify to hear one of these tracks first.
An Unexpected Pop Punk EP That Actually Delivers
Kicking off with “She Said She Didn’t Want Fries,” as performed by Wendy’s, Matty Mullins, and Memphis May Fire, the opening track introduces us to a narrator whose girlfriend said she didn’t want fries (which goes on to rhyme with “she lies”) and, as a result, “her meal was incomplete / now her sin is my tragedy.” The next track takes on a rival fast food chain for soft serve ice cream machine failures, affirming that “there’s no happy in your meal there anymore” amidst “golden notch betrayal” and recommended that “getting to the freckled side” will treat you better. There’s even a pop punk ballad, “I Miss the Sunroom,” which speaks to what it’s like when the Frosty cup is empty.
The concept sounds insane, but this is by no means a parody album. Written by established songwriter and producer Matt Squire, whose past collaborators include Sabrina Carpenter, Ariana Grande, Kesha, All Time Low, and Simple Plan, and performed by Wendy’s and a range of established pop punk and metalcore artists, this was an actual investment. What’s notable about this unique moment in time is that generative AI would make it incredibly easy to write and record a set of songs as a quick publicity stunt. The level of investment in talented creators, the deliberate mix of hyper pop punk, slower ballads, and edgy screamo moments (see “My Frosty’s Funeral”), and the clear dedication to the clever word play pop punk is known for and the high energy choruses makes this more than a stunt.
Can Creative Plays Land When Operations Are Struggling?
The EP rollout happened around the same time as a Wendy’s franchisee announced the planned closure of dozens of restaurants after seeking Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. When I was looking to see who else is writing about this album release, the album news was fully eclipsed by the bankruptcy chatter in the news cycle. This brings the question of whether a creative marketing play can actually flourish when the operational landscape is under scrutiny.
The franchisee troubles are not a surprise when looking at which fast food restaurants are most popular in the US today. Wendy’s is losing the fast food race, coming in at fourth overall with the 55+ demographic leading their current customer base and landing at sixth for the 18-34 demographic.
Is this album the gateway to bringing Wendy’s brand awareness to Gen Alpha through catchy beats? Or is it a nostalgia love letter to Millennials who remember listening to the early 2000s peak of pop punk in fast food drive-thrus? Or perhaps a call to Gen Z – old enough to know pop punk but not old enough to have been a Wendy’s regular at the restaurant’s peak? Perhaps all three. The question here is whether there’s still time for Wendy’s to catch back up amidst the franchisee bankruptcy landscape.
An Outlier That Wouldn’t Survive Most Brainstorming Sessions
Sometimes Strategy Stories covers instances of strategic re-entry in one’s established field, such as Hilary Duff’s 2026 comeback in the pop scene, or creative ways to meet a compliance need in an unexpected way, such as Levi’s social media play during the World Cup amidst strict branding requirements. Wendy’s is doing neither here – this play is about entering an industry that has nothing to do with your core product with a free offering on streaming that is delivering equal levels of shock that it occurred in the first place and that it’s actually quite good.
What can we learn from this move?
What Wendy’s did here is actually focus on the kind of idea that would get killed off in most brainstorming sessions. In brainstorming, there’s often a push to discard outlier, wild ideas, in favor of options falling in the safer quadrants in the impact to effort matrix. Wendy’s made a brave move here with a high effort ploy with an uncertain, yet-to-be-determined impact. On the impact to effort matrix below, I’d estimate this as a high effort but uncertain level of projected impact – putting this potentially in the orange or green box — but this outlier would be hard to plot with confidence anywhere in the grid.
I’ll be curious to see how this plays out both in the music scene in the short-term as well as in early signals of generational shifts in fast food preferences.
What I can tell you though, as a leading indicator, is that I found myself wondering mid-run whether a Frosty is gluten free…
Thanks for reading Strategy Stories by Lavorgna Strategy Studio!
About Strategy Stories
Strategy Stories is built on a single belief: the most useful strategic insights don’t always come from inside your industry. Through this platform, Jackie Lavorgna, PhD, SMP shares case studies, analyses, and anecdotes for curious leaders, strategists, innovators, and futurists — spanning readers throughout the United States and across 16+ countries.
Strategy Stories is the insights vertical of Lavorgna Strategy Studio, a consultancy helping leaders, teams, and organizations prepare and plan for the future through strategic planning and strategic foresight.